Intellyse

Freight Audit Pricing: What Per-Line Fees Really Cost

A per-line fee follows how many invoice lines you have, while most of your freight spend sits in a few large ones.

Comparison · 6 min · Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO, Intellyse · Published · Last updated

By Intellyse, makers of freight invoice audit software · About us

ShareLinkedInXEmail
Invoices marked paid and due beside a calculator, for comparing freight audit pricing and per-line fees
Photo: Tara Winstead on Pexels

Explore this post with AI

Key takeaways
  • Freight audit pricing is commonly set per invoice or invoice line, as a share of recoveries, as a subscription, or as a share of audited spend, and each model follows a different driver of cost.
  • A fixed fee per invoice line costs far more as a share of freight spend when lines are small: at an illustrative EUR 2.90 per line, it is 5.8% of spend on EUR 50 lines and 0.29% on EUR 1,000 lines.
  • Per-line pricing is usually the cheaper choice when lines are few and valuable, so the right model depends on your own line count and line values.

Many shippers compare freight audit pricing on the fee per line, because that is the number on the offer. For a business with few, large invoice lines, that comparison works well. For one with many small lines, the fee per line hides what matters: what the audit costs as a share of freight spend.

How is freight audit priced?

Freight audit is commonly priced in one of four ways: a fee per invoice or invoice line, a share of the money recovered, a subscription, or a share of the freight spend audited. Each follows a different driver, so the same audit can cost very different amounts under each model.

ModelWhat you pay forCost usually grows with
Per invoice or per lineEach invoice or line checked, often with fees per dispute or set-upThe number of lines, and of disputes
Share of recoveries (contingency fee)A percentage of money recoveredThe carrier errors found and recovered
SubscriptionAccess to a tool or service for a periodThe tier or volume band chosen
Share of audited spendA percentage of the freight spend checkedFreight spend

These are typical differences, and many offers combine models, for example a per-line fee with extra charges for reporting or analysis. The table shows what each model tends to follow, not what any one provider charges.

What does a per-line fee cost as a share of freight spend?

A per-line fee costs more, as a share of spend, the less each line is worth. In an illustrative case of EUR 2.50 per line plus EUR 8 per dispute on 5% of lines, about EUR 2.90 per line in total:

Average value per invoice linePer-line fee as a share of freight spend
EUR 50 (parcel, small groupage)5.80%
EUR 150 (groupage, part loads)1.93%
EUR 400 (mixed road)0.73%
EUR 1,000 (full truckload)0.29%
EUR 2,500 (full container, air consolidation)0.12%

The fees are illustrative, not taken from any contract. What matters is how many of your lines are small. In a recent 90-day period of invoices on our platform, more than half the invoice lines were worth less than 50 in the shipper's own currency at eight of nine shippers. At seven of them, those small lines carried between 3% and 17% of freight spend.

Most invoice lines are small, but they carry little of the spend

Lines worth under 50 in the shipper's currency: share of all lines vs share of freight spend, last 90 days of shipments

  • Share of invoice lines (what a per-line fee follows)
  • Share of freight spend
  • Shipper A90.7%99.8%
  • Shipper B12.7%87.6%
  • Shipper C16.9%83.7%
  • Shipper D6.2%74.4%
  • Shipper E7.9%69.9%
  • Shipper F15.6%68.6%
  • Shipper G3.8%64.7%
  • Shipper H2.5%57.8%
  • Shipper I1.0%24.8%
0%25%50%75%100%
Source: invoices audited on the Intellyse platform, shipment dates 17 August to 16 November 2026, freight and surcharge lines with tax and duty excluded, nine shippers with 500 or more lines, each in its own currency.

Surcharges add to the count. A carrier that bills fuel, toll and handling as separate lines raises the line count with no extra freight moved.

A per-line fee follows how many lines you have; the money is in a small number of large ones.

When is per-line pricing the cheaper choice?

Per-line pricing is usually cheaper when lines are few and valuable, such as full containers or full truckloads worth several thousand euros each. A small fixed fee is then a tiny share of each line, and a share of spend can cost more. Do the maths with your own line count and average line value before comparing offers.

Why does the real cost go unnoticed?

Offers are quoted per line, and invoices from the audit provider are paid per period, so the total is rarely set against freight spend. Extras such as dispute fees or reporting arrive as separate items. And the line count moves with carrier invoice layouts, so the audit bill can rise in a year when freight volume does not. For a wider set of criteria, our guide on what to look for in freight audit software covers the rest, and our post on what a freight audit service checks covers the service side.

What to ask at your next freight audit renewal

Questions for your freight audit renewal
Tick each step as you go
  1. What share of our invoice lines did you check last year, and which were left out?
  2. What did we pay in total, including per-dispute and extra fees, as a share of our freight spend?
  3. How has that share changed over the last three years, against our line count?
  4. Can we see, for each flagged line, the rate it was checked against?
  5. How much of what you flagged as a freight overcharge was paid back?
All 5 steps shown

Our Invoice Approval module checks each line against the rate card, including small accessorial charges that are easy to wave through. It shows what differs and what has no agreed rate, line by line, before an invoice is approved. That makes the comparison with any pricing model a question of what is found, not how many lines were counted.

See where your freight money goes

Our Freight X-Ray checks one month of your carrier invoices and shows what you could recover. No cost, no commitment.

  • Send one month of carrier invoices and your rate cards, as file exports
  • Every line checked against your contracted rates, with the reason for each difference
  • Spend by carrier, lane and surcharge, so you can see how many small lines you really have

Prefer to talk first? Pick a time with Alexandre.

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO & Founder of IntellyseYou'll meet Alexandre de Perregaux
CEO & Founder, Intellyse
Loading Alex's calendar…
Start your Freight X-Ray →

FAQ

How is freight audit priced?
Common models are a fee per invoice or invoice line, a share of the money recovered, a subscription, or a share of the freight spend audited, often with set-up or extra-service fees on top. What each costs depends on how many lines you have and what they are worth.
When is per-line freight audit pricing cheaper?
It is usually cheaper when lines are few and valuable, such as full containers or full truckloads, because a small fixed fee is then a tiny share of each line. With many small lines, such as parcels, groupage or surcharges billed separately, the same fee becomes a much larger share of spend.
What should I ask my freight audit provider at renewal?
Ask what share of your invoice lines was checked, what you paid in total as a share of freight spend, and how that share has moved. Ask to see the rate each flagged line was checked against, and how much of what was flagged came back.

About the author

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO, Intellyse

Alexandre de Perregaux is CEO of Intellyse. Intellyse builds freight invoice auditing software in Zurich that checks carrier invoices against contracts and shipment data across ocean, air, parcel and road.

ShareLinkedInXEmail
Start your Freight X-Ray
A container ship at sea under an evening sky

Freight X-Ray

Are you overpaying for freight?

Forward one month of carrier invoices. Within a week you see what you overpay and what you could save every month.

Get your free Freight X-Ray
Overcharged game map: a ship on a route from Zurich and Rotterdam via Suez towards Singapore and Shanghai

The daily freight quiz

Play Overcharged

One route, three stops and a number to guess at each stop. Everyone gets the same route on the same day.

Play today’s route