Intellyse

What a Freight Audit Service Checks Before You Sign

What an audit finds depends on the references it is given, and what it recovers depends on who follows each claim to a credit note.

Explainer · 6 min · Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO, Intellyse · Published · Last updated

By Intellyse, makers of freight invoice audit software · About us

ShareLinkedInXEmail
A worker in an orange work suit and yellow hard hat stands on top of a blue shipping container on a ship's deck, checking a sheet of paperwork
Photo: Simon R. Minshall on Pexels

Explore this post with AI

Key takeaways
  • Invoice audit services for freight compare each carrier invoice line with the contracted rates, the surcharge terms, the shipment record and earlier invoices, and raise a query or a claim where they differ.
  • A pre-payment audit flags an incorrect invoice before it is paid so it can be held or corrected; a post-payment audit seeks recovery afterwards through claims, refunds or credit notes, which depends on the carrier accepting the claim.
  • What a service can find depends on what it is given: without the rate card, surcharge tables and shipment data, an audit can usually check arithmetic and duplicates, but not price.

Many searches for invoice audit services are about accounts payable in general: someone checks supplier invoices against purchase orders and recovers what was overpaid. Freight works on the same principle, and a service that checks carrier invoices that way will find duplicates and arithmetic slips. What it can miss is the price itself, because a freight invoice is checked against a rate card, a surcharge table and a shipment record, not a purchase order.

What does a freight audit service check?

A freight audit service can check each line of a carrier invoice against the reference that should have priced it: the contracted base rate for the shipment date, the surcharge terms, the weights and dimensions in the shipment record, the Incoterm on the order, and the invoices already received. A line that does not match is held, queried or claimed.

The checks below are the typical ones, the same you would run to check a freight invoice yourself; which of them a given service runs depends on the data it receives.

CheckCompared againstWhat a mismatch usually suggests
Base rateThe rate card and validity period that applied to the shipment dateA rate from an expired validity period or the wrong lane
Surcharges and accessorial chargesThe contract, surcharge table or tariff it incorporatesA surcharge with no contracted rate, or a fuel percentage from the wrong period
Weight and dimensionsThe shipment recordBilled weight above what was shipped
Duplicate invoicesEarlier invoices for the same shipmentThe same charge billed twice
Commercial termsThe order and its IncotermA charge billed to a party that, under the agreed terms, was not expected to bear it

Each finding is grounds for a query, not proof of an overcharge; the contract and any tariff incorporated into it decide what was payable.

Surcharges are where a base-rate check runs out. In the invoices audited on our platform in the first half of 2026, across all transport modes, surcharges made up about 30 per cent of invoiced freight spend, excluding taxes and duties. A service that compares only the base rate with the rate card does not check that share at all.

A freight audit is only as good as the reference it checks against.

What does a freight audit service need, and what are you buying?

A freight audit service needs the invoices and the references that priced them: rate cards and contracts with their validity periods, surcharge tables or the tariffs the contract incorporates, shipment data with weights and dates, the Incoterm on each order, and the claim rules and deadlines in each carrier agreement. With invoices alone, it can find duplicates and arithmetic errors but cannot independently verify a contracted rate.

What a service does with a finding varies as much as what it checks. Some return a report of discrepancies; some also file the claim with the carrier; some follow each claim to an outcome and confirm that the credit note arrived. Those are different services, and a proposal should say which one it is; the same question applies when comparing freight audit tools with outsourced services.

Pre-payment vs post-payment freight audit: which one are you buying?

Freight audits run either before payment or after it, and many services offer both. A pre-payment audit identifies an incorrect invoice before payment, so it can be held, queried or corrected; a post-payment audit reviews invoices already paid and seeks recovery through claims, refunds or credit notes.

Pre-payment auditPost-payment audit
When it runsBefore the payment runWeeks or months after payment
What it needsRates, surcharge terms and shipment data in time for each runThe same data, plus the carrier's claim process and deadlines
How the money comes backThe invoice is held, queried or corrected before paymentA claim is accepted and a credit note or refund issued
Commercial modelFixed fee, subscription or per transactionFixed fee, subscription or recovery-based

These are typical differences, not rules. A post-payment audit can uncover issues that escaped pre-payment checks, particularly when it covers a longer period or runs deeper checks, but every finding then has to travel through a claim. Carrier contracts or applicable tariffs may set deadlines for raising billing disputes, so a finding made after the deadline may be correct and no longer recoverable. Recovery-based pricing, also called a contingency fee, gainshare or success fee, is common in post-payment services, but fixed and subscription models exist too.

Why do audited overcharges go unrecovered?

Because a finding is a list and recovery is a process. An audit report can name every deviation and still recover nothing if no one files the claims, answers the carrier's questions and checks that the credit note arrived.

The gaps are typically between teams. The audit service or the logistics team finds the deviation; carrier claim management sits with whoever holds the carrier relationship; the credit note lands in accounts payable, often against a different invoice number from the one it corrects. A claim that is accepted but never matched to a credit note looks closed in one system and open in another. Fee models add their own blind spot: a share of the amount "identified" or "claimed" is not the same as a share of the amount credited.

MeasureWhat it means
IdentifiedThe audit found a discrepancy
ClaimedA claim was submitted to the carrier
AcceptedThe carrier agreed to the claim
CreditedA credit note or refund arrived and was matched

These are four different numbers. Ask which one a provider reports as recovery.

What should you ask before signing with a freight audit service?

Questions to ask before signing
Tick each step as you go
  1. What references does it check against? Rate cards, surcharge tables, fuel indices, shipment data and the Incoterm on the order, and what it does with a charge that has no contracted rate at all.
  2. Does it audit before or after payment? If after, who files the freight overcharge claim, who follows it, and within which deadline in your carrier contracts.
  3. How is each finding evidenced? The invoice line, the reference it was checked against and the difference, in a form the carrier can verify.
  4. How is recovery measured? Amounts identified, claimed, accepted or credited. Only a credit note matched to the invoice it corrects is money.
  5. What happens when a carrier rejects a claim? Whether the rejection reason is recorded, the claim is re-filed or escalated where the evidence supports it, and it stays open until it is resolved.
All 5 steps shown

An invoice audit that stops at the report leaves the expensive part, credit note recovery, to the team that had no time for it in the first place. Our Dispute Agent for freight overcharge claims takes the audit past the finding: each deviation becomes a claim with its evidence attached, and each credit note is matched back to the shipment, so the result is measured in credits received rather than deviations found. To see what an audit of your own invoices would find, we run a Freight X-Ray on 100 of your shipments, at no cost.

See where your freight money goes

Our Freight X-Ray checks one month of your carrier invoices and shows what you could recover. No cost, no commitment.

  • You send one month of recent invoices with the matching shipment data and rate agreements, as file exports.
  • We check every line against the contracted rates, surcharge terms and shipment data and return the lines that do not match, with the reason for each.
  • You see which deviations warrant a claim, and the evidence that goes with each one.

Prefer to talk first? Pick a time with Alexandre.

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO & Founder of IntellyseYou'll meet Alexandre de Perregaux
CEO & Founder, Intellyse
Loading Alex's calendar…
Start your Freight X-Ray →

FAQ

What is the difference between invoice audit services and a freight audit?
Invoice audit services is the broader term for checking supplier invoices against the documents and pricing rules that should govern them. A freight audit applies that process to carrier invoices, using rate cards, surcharge terms, shipment data and other freight-specific references.
How are freight invoice audit services usually paid?
Common models are a share of the amount recovered, a fee per invoice or a subscription. The basis changes the incentive, so ask whether a recovery fee is charged on amounts claimed or on amounts actually credited.
Can an invoice audit find overcharges without a rate card?
It can find duplicates, arithmetic errors and charges billed twice, but without the rate card and surcharge tables it cannot tell whether a price is right. A charge with no contracted rate at all is a finding in its own right.

About the author

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO, Intellyse

Alexandre de Perregaux is CEO of Intellyse. Intellyse builds freight invoice auditing software in Zurich that checks carrier invoices against contracts and shipment data across ocean, air, parcel and road.

ShareLinkedInXEmail
Start your Freight X-Ray