Intellyse

Air & Parcel Audit Identifies CHF 1.05M in Annual Savings with CHF 313K Already Realized

How a Swiss machine manufacturer achieved full freight cost transparency and realized immediate savings through AI-powered invoice auditing of air and parcel shipments.

Published · Updated

Explore this case study with AI

5,906

Shipments Audited

CHF 2.03M

Spend Audited

CHF 1.05M/yr

Savings Identified

CHF 313K/yr

Already Realized

Company Profile

Industry
Industrial Machinery & Equipment
Headquarters
Switzerland
Annual Revenue
Approx. CHF 1.4 Billion / year
Annual Freight Spend
CHF 35 Million / year
Focus Area
Spare Parts & Aftermarket Logistics

What challenges existed before the audit?

The company shipped thousands of spare parts globally via air freight and parcel carriers, but had no automated way to verify whether invoiced charges matched contracted rates. Spend and volume data was extremely difficult to retrieve from SAP, making cost analysis nearly impossible. Shipments were often sent using incorrect Incoterms, lightweight parcels were routed through expensive air freight carriers instead of cheaper parcel services, and carriers applied unfavourable foreign exchange rates — all invisible without line-item level invoice auditing. The true cost split was unknown: roughly 70% freight and 30% unforeseen surcharges.

How did Intellyse audit 994 invoices across 5 carriers?

Intellyse audited 994 invoices covering 5,906 shipments across 5 carriers (3 air freight, 2 express/parcel) over a 5-month period, analysing CHF 2.03M in freight spend. Every line item was validated against contracted rates, Incoterm guidelines, weight thresholds, and FX benchmarks to identify overpayments, misallocations, and optimization opportunities.

Pilot Duration
5 months
Invoices Audited
994
Line Items Checked
5,906 shipments
Carriers Audited
5
Spend Analysed
CHF 2.03M (CHF 4.87M/year)
Transport Mode
Air Freight & Parcel/Express
  1. Month 1–2

    Platform Launch

    5 carriers onboarded, tariff ingestion

  2. Month 3–4

    Analysis & Findings

    5,906 shipments processed

  3. Month 5

    Actions & Savings

    CHF 313K/yr realized, credit notes claimed

How much did the air freight audit save?

Savings identified across 5 carriers in a 5 months analysis

CHF 1.05M

Yearly Savings Identified

CHF 313K/yr

Savings Already Realized

CHF 14K

Credit Notes Recovered

263+

Hours Saved per Year

70% Freight + 30% Surcharges

Cost Transparency

Under 1 year

ROI Timeline

CHF 313K/year already realized (weight threshold + credit notes). Remaining opportunities in active implementation.

What billing errors did the audit uncover?

Deep-dive into the 5 key saving opportunities uncovered across 5 carriers

Lightweight Shipments via Wrong CarrierExplore detailsClose details

803 shipments under 45 kg were routed through an expensive air freight carrier instead of a significantly cheaper parcel/express service. By applying a simple weight threshold rule, the optimal carrier mix reduced costs from CHF 207,550 to CHF 82,250 for the same shipments. This action has been implemented — the shipping department now uses the parcel carrier for all sub-45 kg shipments.

CHF 299K
Yearly saving
803 in 5 months
Affected shipments
60% on affected routes
Cost reduction
Realized
Status

Recommended Actions

  • Weight threshold rule implemented — sub-45 kg shipments now routed to parcel carrier
Incorrect Incoterms (DDP instead of CIF/CPT)Explore detailsClose details

366 shipments were sent using DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) instead of the company’s standard CIF/CPT terms. This meant the company was absorbing destination charges, overseas duties, taxes, and storage fees that should have been paid by the customer. Switching to the correct Incoterms eliminates these avoidable costs entirely.

CHF 648K
Yearly saving opportunity
366 in 5 months
DDP shipments found
Duties, taxes, storage
Avoidable surcharges

Recommended Actions

  • Incoterm compliance enforced — duties and taxes now paid by customer where applicable
Unfavourable Foreign Exchange RatesExplore detailsClose details

Rate cards were denominated in EUR, CNY, INR, and USD, but invoices were billed in CHF. The carrier applied its own FX rates instead of ECB reference rates, resulting in 5–8% higher costs on currency conversion. By paying carriers in local currency through the company’s own bank, these inflated FX margins are eliminated.

CHF 74K
Yearly saving opportunity
5–8% above ECB rates
FX markup

Recommended Actions

  • Pay carriers in local currency via own bank to use favourable FX rates
Duplicate Handling & Pick-Up SurchargesExplore detailsClose details

Every email pre-alert to the carrier triggered handling and pick-up surcharges — even when multiple alerts were for the same shipment. 135 shipments were affected by duplicate surcharges within the pilot period. Consolidating pre-alerts to a maximum of one per shipment eliminates these unnecessary fees.

CHF 26K
Yearly saving opportunity
135
Affected shipments

Recommended Actions

  • Pre-alert process optimized — maximum one notification per shipment to avoid duplicate surcharges
Credit Note RecoveryExplore detailsClose details

Direct invoice errors identified and claimed back from carriers. CHF 14K in credit notes have already been recovered through the streamlined claiming process enabled by the platform.

CHF 14K
Recovered
Realized
Status

Recommended Actions

  • Credit notes claimed and received — ongoing automated detection continues

How did freight invoice control change?

6 gaps identified. Intellyse closes every one.

  • Before

    Spend and volume data extremely difficult to retrieve from SAP

    With Intellyse

    Immediate spend and volume analysis across all carriers and shipments

  • Before

    Manual invoice checks consuming significant staff time

    With Intellyse

    Fully automated auditing — 263+ hours per year saved

  • Before

    No visibility on true cost split between freight and surcharges

    With Intellyse

    Full transparency: 70% freight + 30% surcharges clearly separated

  • Before

    Lightweight parcels routed through expensive air freight carriers

    With Intellyse

    Weight threshold optimization — CHF 299K/year realized by using the right carrier

  • Before

    Incorrect Incoterms causing the company to absorb customer duties and taxes

    With Intellyse

    Incoterm compliance enforced — CHF 648K/year in avoidable costs identified

  • Before

    No visibility on non-negotiated lanes or FX rate markups

    With Intellyse

    Full transparency on all lanes, surcharges, and carrier FX margins

What does the logistics team say?

We no longer need manual checks — the team can focus on core competencies instead of chasing invoice discrepancies.
Head of Logistics, Spare Parts Division
The cost transparency alone was worth it. We had no idea that 30% of our freight cost was surcharges we couldn’t even see in SAP.
Procurement Manager

Related product modules

Ready to uncover your hidden savings?

Our Freight X-Ray checks one month of your carrier invoices and shows what you could recover. No cost, no commitment.

Start your Freight X-Ray
A container ship at sea under an evening sky

Freight X-Ray

Are you overpaying for freight?

Forward one month of carrier invoices. Within a week you see what you overpay and what you could save every month.

Get your free Freight X-Ray
Overcharged game map: a ship on a route from Zurich and Rotterdam via Suez towards Singapore and Shanghai

The daily freight quiz

Play Overcharged

One route, three stops and a number to guess at each stop. Everyone gets the same route on the same day.

Play today’s route