Intellyse

Incorrect Freight Charges: What 445,000 Invoice Lines Show

Most incorrect freight charges are not wrong prices but charges nobody agreed to, and they need a different check.

Finding · 7 min · Sebastian Bensland, CTO, Intellyse · Published · Last updated

By Intellyse, makers of freight invoice audit software · About us

ShareLinkedInXEmail
Two people at a grey table, one pointing at a line on printed forms, with a pen, a phone and a tablet beside them
Photo: Olena Kholina on Unsplash

Explore this post with AI

Key takeaways
  • Of 444,965 invoice lines checked on the Intellyse platform for nine clients, on invoices from November 2025 to October 2026, 43% matched the agreed rate, 11% were billed above it and 4% were above it only because of the exchange rate used.
  • A further 15% were charges with no agreed rate at all, the error most often approved without a question, because there is nothing to compare it with.
  • Overcharges came to between 0.4% and 6.7% of invoiced spend per client, and 7% of lines were billed below the agreed rate, so a check of invoice totals hides errors in both directions.

Most teams look for incorrect freight charges by comparing an invoice total with what they expected to pay, and querying anything far out of line. That catches the big mistakes, and it is the check finance can run on every invoice. What it misses is the pattern underneath: when we checked 444,965 invoice lines for nine clients, the most common problem was not a wrong price but a charge for which no price had been agreed.

What do incorrect freight charges look like?

An incorrect freight charge is an invoice line that differs from what the contract, the shipment and the agreed exchange rate say it should be. In our data, four kinds account for 37% of all lines: charges above the agreed rate, charges inflated by the exchange rate, charges with no agreed rate and charges below the agreed rate.

Only 43% of invoice lines matched the agreed rate

444,965 base freight and surcharge lines by check result, invoices November 2025 to October 2026

  • Matched the agreed rate43%
  • Above the agreed rate11%
  • Above it through the exchange rate4%
  • No agreed rate for this charge15%
  • Below the agreed rate7%
  • Taxes, duties, spot quotes and charges without a stored rate20%
Source: Intellyse platform, nine clients. Share of all lines checked.
ResultLinesShareWhat it means
Matched the agreed rate190,23943%Billed as contracted
Above the agreed rate49,67111%Wrong rate, weight band, validity date or surcharge basis
Above it through the exchange rate19,6124%Right rate, converted at a rate worse than the reference
No agreed rate for this charge64,68615%A charge type the contract does not mention
Below the agreed rate32,0907%Billed under the contract
Taxes, duties, spot quotes and charges without a stored rate88,66720%Checked against other documents, or not checkable against a contract rate

Base freight and surcharges fail differently. Of 146,235 base freight lines, 16% were above the agreed rate; of 298,730 surcharge lines, 9% were. Exchange rate differences sat mostly on freight lines: 15,430 against 4,182 on surcharges. Charges with no agreed rate were mostly surcharges: 45,099 lines, against 19,587 base freight lines.

At invoice level, 2,599 of the 10,052 invoices (26%) carried at least one line above the agreed rate, and 4,754 (47%) at least one charge with no agreed rate.

Can AI identify incorrect freight charges?

Yes, wherever there is a reference to compare against. AI reads the line, maps it to the agreed rate, the shipment and the exchange rate, and flags the difference with the source. Where no rate was agreed, which was 15% of lines here, AI can flag the charge and show where it appeared before, but someone has to decide whether it is owed. The five checks behind this are set out in what AI checks on every freight invoice line.

Incorrect chargeWhat AI doesWhat a person decides
Above the agreed rateRecomputes the charge from the rate card, weight, lane and date, and cites the clauseWhether to claim it
Inflated by the exchange rateCompares the rate used with the reference the contract names, such as the ECB reference rate on the invoice dateWhich reference applies if the contract is silent
No agreed rateGroups the charge by type and carrier, shows how often it was billed beforeWhether it is owed, and whether to add it to the contract
Below the agreed rateFlags the lineWhether to accept it or net it in a claim
Billed twiceMatches shipment references across invoicesWhich invoice to reject

The hard part for software is the label, not the arithmetic. The same charge is worded differently by every carrier: on our platform, fuel surcharges alone appeared under 316 different wordings in the same twelve months. Our post on what carrier invoice validation software has to read covers how those wordings are mapped to one charge type before any rate is compared.

A charge with no agreed rate cannot fail a rate check, which is why it is the error most often paid.

Why do incorrect freight charges go unnoticed?

Because approval looks at totals, and totals net errors out. Lines above and below the agreed rate cancel each other on the invoice, a charge with no agreed rate has nothing to fail against, and an exchange rate difference never appears as a line of its own. Each error is small, so none of them stands out.

The amounts are not small in sum. Overcharges against agreed rates came to between 0.4% and 6.7% of each client's invoiced spend, and at six of the nine clients most of that was on base freight rather than surcharges, so a check limited to surcharges would have missed most of it. Our audit of a machine manufacturer's air and parcel invoices found FX markups of 5 to 8 percent above the ECB rate, worth CHF 74K a year, none of it visible on a single line.

What can you do about it this week?

This week's line check
Tick each step as you go
  1. Take one month of invoices from your largest carrier and list every distinct charge type on them.
  2. Mark each charge type that has no rate in the contract, and add up what was paid under it.
  3. Recompute ten base freight lines from the rate card, including weight band and validity date.
  4. Check the exchange rate on five invoices billed in a currency other than your contract currency against the reference your contract names.
All 4 steps shown

Our Invoice Approval module for checking carrier invoices before approval runs these checks on every line and holds anything that fails, with the rate, shipment and exchange rate behind each flag.

See where your freight money goes

Our Freight X-Ray checks one month of your carrier invoices and shows what you could recover. No cost, no commitment.

  • You share invoices and shipment data for 100 recent shipments, plus the rate agreements behind them.
  • We check every line against the agreed rate, the shipment and the reference exchange rate.
  • You receive the breakdown above for your own invoices, with each flagged line and its source.

Prefer to talk first? Pick a time with Alexandre.

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO & Founder of IntellyseYou'll meet Alexandre de Perregaux
CEO & Founder, Intellyse
Loading Alex's calendar…
Start your Freight X-Ray →

FAQ

Can AI identify incorrect freight charges?
Yes, wherever there is a reference to compare against: AI reads each line, maps it to the agreed rate, the shipment and the exchange rate, and flags the difference. For charges with no agreed rate it can flag the line and show where the charge appeared before, but a person decides whether it is owed.
What are the most common freight invoice errors?
In 444,965 invoice lines we checked, 15% were charges with no agreed rate, 11% were billed above the agreed rate and 4% were above it only because of the exchange rate used. Another 7% were billed below the agreed rate.
Can AI check if a carrier charged us the right amount?
It can recompute what the carrier should have charged from the rate card, the shipment's weight, lane and date, the fuel index and the reference exchange rate, and compare it with each billed line. It needs your current rate agreements to do so.

About the author

Sebastian Bensland, CTO, Intellyse

Sebastian Bensland is CTO and co-founder of Intellyse. Intellyse builds freight invoice auditing software in Zurich that checks carrier invoices against contracts and shipment data across ocean, air, parcel and road.

Sources

  1. European Central Bank, Euro foreign exchange reference ratesecb.europa.eu · 2026
ShareLinkedInXEmail
Start your Freight X-Ray
A container ship at sea under an evening sky

Freight X-Ray

Are you overpaying for freight?

Forward one month of carrier invoices. Within a week you see what you overpay and what you could save every month.

Get your free Freight X-Ray
Overcharged game map: a ship on a route from Zurich and Rotterdam via Suez towards Singapore and Shanghai

The daily freight quiz

Play Overcharged

One route, three stops and a number to guess at each stop. Everyone gets the same route on the same day.

Play today’s route