Intellyse

Road Toll Surcharge: Why It Drifts From the Contract

A fixed toll in a rate card can go out of date as toll tables change, leaving the amount billed above or below the agreed rate.

Update · 6 min · Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO, Intellyse · Published · Last updated

By Intellyse, makers of freight invoice audit software · About us

ShareLinkedInXEmail
A lorry on a European motorway, the kind of road freight a road toll surcharge is billed on per kilometre
Photo: Alban Mehmeti on Pexels

Explore this post with AI

Key takeaways
  • A road toll surcharge is the share of a truck's road tolls that a carrier bills on to each shipment, calculated from a zone table, the actual route toll or a percentage of freight, depending on the contract.
  • From 1 July 2026, Toll Collect changed how certain German trucks over 16 tonnes are assigned to CO2 emission classes, and it says the new categorisation leads to higher toll costs.
  • Whether a changed toll line is payable depends on the contract's toll clause, so the check is the toll basis and table the carrier used, not only the amount.

On 1 July 2026, Germany changed how certain trucks over 16 tonnes are placed in CO2 emission classes, which set the CO2 part of the Lkw-Maut. Many shippers agreed toll surcharges in the rate card at tender and treat them as a pass-through that needs no check. That holds while the toll tables stand still, and in 2026 they did not.

What is a road toll surcharge?

A road toll surcharge is the share of a truck's road tolls that a carrier bills on to each shipment, as a separate line beside the freight rate. It is called Mautzuschlag on many German-language invoices, and it can cover several countries on one shipment.

In its notice of 1 July 2026, Toll Collect said the limit values that place a truck in a CO2 emission class are falling for certain trucks over 16 tonnes, following EU rules adopted in December 2025. A truck previously in CO2 class 3 may fall into class 2 or 1. Class 1 carries the highest CO2-related toll charge, so this can raise the toll per kilometre, which also depends on the vehicle's weight, axles and pollutant class.

How is a road toll surcharge calculated?

Road toll surcharges can be structured in several ways, depending on the carrier agreement, and some contracts combine them. Three common approaches are a zone table, a pass-through and a percentage. A zone table sets a toll amount per shipment by distance zone and weight band, fixed in the rate card. A pass-through bills a share of the actual toll for the route, which moves when the toll tariff, the route or the truck's CO2 class moves. A percentage adds a fixed share of freight, which moves only with the freight rate.

A toll in a rate card is a snapshot of the toll table on the day the contract was signed.

When the carrier's own toll cost changes and the contract allows it to pass that on, the invoice line moves while the rate card stays where it was.

Why does the toll on a freight invoice not match the contract?

The line and the rate card usually part because one of them was updated and the other was not, and the difference can go either way. In the road freight invoices we audited for shipments between June and mid-November 2026, across seven shippers, 3,172 toll lines could be compared with a toll rate in the rate card: 1,190 were billed above it and 194 below.

One shipper accounts for most toll lines billed above the rate card

3,172 road toll lines at seven shippers, compared with the contracted toll; each square is about 1% of lines

  • Billed above, one shipper1,040 lines · 33%
  • Billed above, other shippers150 lines · 5%
  • Billed below194 lines · 6%
  • At contracted toll1,788 lines · 56%
Source: road invoices audited on the Intellyse platform, shipment dates 1 June to 16 November 2026, seven shippers.

Almost all the above-contract differences came from one shipper, where 1,040 of 1,041 classified toll lines were billed about 40% above the contracted toll. That is 40% on the toll line itself, not on the shipper's total freight cost. At a second shipper the lines drifted in both directions by small amounts, and at five shippers they matched. A difference of that shape suggests the carrier and the rate card are working from different toll tables, which is grounds for a question, not proof of an overcharge.

Why do toll surcharges go unchecked?

Toll is often treated as a government charge passed through at cost, so approvers leave it out of the rate check. The lines are small per shipment and spread across many zones and weight bands, so a 40% step shows only when a month of lines is added up. A CO2 reclassification does not appear on the invoice at all: the line simply carries a new amount under the same description.

What to do about it

Checking toll lines against the contract
Tick each step as you go
  1. Find the toll basis in each road contract: zone table, pass-through or percentage, and the notice the carrier must give before changing it.
  2. Ask each carrier which toll table version it bills from, and the CO2 class of the vehicles on your lanes.
  3. Add up a month of toll lines per lane and compare them with the rate card; a lane analysis shows a step faster than a line-by-line check.
  4. Agree an update rule for toll changes, with a date and a source table, so the rate card and the invoice move together, and build the toll into your freight cost per shipment rather than leaving it as an extra.
All 4 steps shown

Our Cost to Serve module shows when the cost of a lane moves, so the team knows which toll lines to compare with the contract first. Toll drift hides across thousands of small lines, and a cost to serve analysis by lane and month is where it surfaces.

See where your freight money goes

Our Freight X-Ray checks one month of your carrier invoices and shows what you could recover. No cost, no commitment.

  • Send one month of road freight invoices and your rate cards or contract terms, as file exports
  • Every line checked against your contracted rates, toll lines included, with the reason for each difference
  • Spend by carrier, lane and surcharge, so a toll step shows up per lane

Prefer to talk first? Pick a time with Alexandre.

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO & Founder of IntellyseYou'll meet Alexandre de Perregaux
CEO & Founder, Intellyse
Loading Alex's calendar…
Start your Freight X-Ray →

FAQ

What is a road toll surcharge?
A road toll surcharge is the share of a truck's road tolls that a carrier bills on to each shipment, as a separate line beside the freight rate. Common approaches are a toll table per zone or weight band, a share of the actual toll on the route, or a percentage of freight, depending on the contract.
Can a carrier change the toll surcharge during a contract?
That depends on the contract: some fix the toll in the rate card, some allow the carrier to pass on toll changes with notice, and some bill actual tolls. Check the toll clause and any notice the carrier sent before treating a changed line as an error.
Why did my toll charges in Germany change in 2026?
From 1 July 2026, Toll Collect changed how certain trucks over 16 tonnes are assigned to CO2 emission classes, and it says the new categorisation leads to higher toll costs. Whether that reached your invoices depends on the vehicles your carrier uses and how your contract handles toll changes.

About the author

Alexandre de Perregaux, CEO, Intellyse

Alexandre de Perregaux is CEO of Intellyse. Intellyse builds freight invoice auditing software in Zurich that checks carrier invoices against contracts and shipment data across ocean, air, parcel and road.

Sources

  1. Toll Collect, CO2 toll: classification of vehicles is changingtoll-collect.de · 1 July 2026
ShareLinkedInXEmail
Start your Freight X-Ray
A container ship at sea under an evening sky

Freight X-Ray

Are you overpaying for freight?

Forward one month of carrier invoices. Within a week you see what you overpay and what you could save every month.

Get your free Freight X-Ray
Overcharged game map: a ship on a route from Zurich and Rotterdam via Suez towards Singapore and Shanghai

The daily freight quiz

Play Overcharged

One route, three stops and a number to guess at each stop. Everyone gets the same route on the same day.

Play today’s route